*ilonrIf- EsIilt T0 ItIU ??:rt nr:tur E)lDn "lnrnl tr?nll)l !u ntntyy nr)lnf I]xly;t 7w aru ?J.l.lpn ,n?Nly nrytypn nt-.lgD nT ryvtix ly rr y-T)n ,rJll)n ?"rn nngur Etulu/it )fnDn ,nl1lyl tr)Ilt-tR E?)lJ)p ?yl OlUrtn nnrn? n?n:nn 'rI ;'l!rpnlu 'rlfTt p/? s.nnr:l ntr)'Inl nun rplDnt ,trrJiTrllr nr?r:x? ;-rrn-n l?l ngr'r?xl nnn?n ?U .,ptnn n"?yil n?;-l E):,-l?n n]xlyn] nnn)nn fnX .?D'l]n ry?l'tnn nl"l?u 7'On rg'rltDn 'Nlyn ngDln <{ t9].1 nN yDqJT no,rr y-r')3r 79D DnNUJ n)7 lntN rlN" :ntD rNl UJDD Dt'n .noTnln ntyu Dryto rl9rit 'Nlyn ngDln nN InuJlg D ti tUJrN Ntit .;r)11D y'tnqJ .nnn?D7 nllDnD nllrN nrlD-]) "ltDN D nn? tuigN (s-n lrprnn) l?yllrn;-r n)n:n ?y DDrr;r rpnn;'r l-ryn ru) 1tl:n nun ltl nutyn) nT n)n .n:rnn rru,n ?ur ntnt:?t 7'tvn) l)y)'Ilnn nx pso) u-l'I3u/ i'lllnil ttwn).1lD?xn lrynn lrpni'ru/ y'T?nn 1nu ?v Er)rTnn ,.llD)Nn -1ryn ,o): Etx?nt i'll't'lln nl?tfnD t)n s-n .nr-r)pr) n:.lnn ru) nT l"lyn l'l!l n);'l nr?nrts n?tx -nntTNil n'ltnrnn-l 'tDlu r?lgtx? nrl: )u/ ;rJrnil -Tru/nl l.,y?-rnn ?ttn7w Erl'lDn nu'r -: ?rysl n?nn ,'nnrrNn n'rnTnn' ,(cRU) n'rvyrnn yr-rxl n)ysr ,nnnpill -rg"ru ?nnu ,tnx n:pJf ,1ese )y top:nn nu.t:n 1w n?nr-r'rpn .194s -Ty - tr1)u) ?rn nrplnptD ytrn? nnttt n'ly/)p :ly1 grjryiT 1y prpDVn nrlnil .n):):n -Trunl'l rn-lln r?nx;r 6rp11it tr).,ntlnt prry'D! E?-lprp nlyt nnrrn tglu nn))il n]rfrDn nnN) n!"lyl u/r:,fn nutulu uy It)lX tryl (ngtYt rntln Xlvn 'Ti75n ?p tntr:tn ?rp! t? nturRu/ n-Il'ly ,'ul'lu" nl',nu/nnt n)rtn tr))-'lpryn nup);'1 6.rt lty ?y: rruvt rprl1g ytr71 x:vn )y iz,'nn yr,n r!?: nnn?nn 1?nn: nu.rrn )u nnr! ry n1!ry!1 fll)1!r;1,nny'ry,ntn'lf 'l-ID - rnun )r)u y-T)n lf lrnlr ,t,nRn )rnl nD)?unr xlyl lEln ']u/gN .nnnln? n.::pnn nJJ)N nrn']t r3 r) lprrp rlu nrrrizn: IrnN nn? T'ryn -re"ru u?rx 2.1nx'n nnt .yTtnnn t-run nN nlu, :trgtlp1Du' ll ?y rnyt ,(MakarM.Volosiuk) i/PDhr ):r)r;z rprrl) yrtr1T]?l 23: nlPD'ln nN xv?u./ ,ngDjn 'lnyl ?D]]n ?''l?'l'lxi'l ngDrn ?f ']g)D N'ri''r.nrnril']nurlgn n?rnn r:g? nn]gD nryu/ rsru? rtpn) p'ty\rva ntt,')n:nn'!x xrir: tnNv rlt 'pr:'? rnryn D ("ts"tu ?u rtpln Ep/)lurxt rDX":i''r!T'ri'r nvnvnnn nrnuir nlpnn) yllJt t?nty?T, nx ?trrn u,)x ,'tu'tx ]nl E TNy./ trntnu/n )trrn 'pttn .nrut .nrlxxn nhnynn rnx ?)rp.r 1?r )rvst p?nl 'Py?l'rn ,: )rrrn 'D'nn )u' nJn?xn mr:n ?y t? rtpn) ?:tn "...1s44 rlt YllBn X? nr:nu Ey nnntnn nt?y) nnrrn nl?ny plUD El?Dp )ur "nJn)Nn tn''ll;t^ l'tn ,n?Jnlln n5pfln, ntJ]ulx-tn n]yur ,r''l ']P]?l trrun ,nr.rn ?: 1r1p, rDN ,(l?nt rNr) nrnl]nn b 'nf 'luxf t.nryptrttgrn'nn;''r D J??'Ty 'Iung/ 'rryn ,N ]?rxn nN lrrn?' trt'Ixn Nf,yn ?'IpEn) .lu/]N )ur nUrrttUnn nl'pn)n nlnu, -lnx' nI n?n ')ur, .n)D.l-.I nuu 1tn) nrrunt?rp n).1u! Tn-.lln Nlyn rot'til l,ytTttrit lnV |ll nTn'tln nprlsn )11/ rprrrllp;1 py?'Ilnn :ITPDID I'l'l!'l''ll .nJfi]n 11VnLlV Py?llnn nl']?u . .Ergil l'lv./n ?u.r 1'Y'11Pn n1'l?u ' ):pnn l?y?'T'lnn l-lyn nx )}: rux run nll'PJn .lNl lJtr?? x? )nrn -lnunt (NKVD) ?u:: xu,: (GRU 'T?nyt ,RU) ?Nrvn J?y?lrnn nr'1',u, (nltnx nn?n rnf) ns'nrNl nnnln? py?l'rnn n:li''r .nnnlnn 1?nn: ntt?nn J?Y?Tlnn'l )y rpry: DDlnn fy,Tlnn n11-,a L?v TID?xn llyn .E??tpry tr?f?l-ln nvfru ?)r rux (HUMINT) u:?nt? ,nnDnr ,E?'tnN pi79r rly:t El)Nlvn orngDln )ln"E nuy]nn n?rr 'tut n]?unr)g?'T;'] nt?]i?yJl nt ?)::r - 'T!rn n1v-1xl u,?nvan trrf1D ,o?tyn nl?uD?JlnlPn ntrlsnn ?-ltnl - nlJlv., ngl'px n'tJ?Tnf avlnv alru:rnipr E?'I lxn r?n -rpfx tlp n?tyr ?u nt ntvy '1lynu/ prv) s,r .nfpDlnl n?il mt;l3n ntllgnn )rln lnr?llft ,th: nltyr trTy??Dl ETflD 11r11!1yr1p ntf?Dn tp?yl tlyg,n'l?uDT.tn'tpn rtry t?ys 1f, lnl .lnl?l nnlll il?Ylu'rn rly: Pnt - "n?n rll-lx' )p :nr lun ?Dl"rn py?l'rnn nr'l?u, ln?-tln -lp/N ny ?lnf't trT'tn?y ,prryupD tr?l]l?N .1 11 ,Dy,rgZs ,O,7Upr ,DrlJry ,,lE ilDtINn nlnrnn igro ttgtX? .Z David E, Murphy, What Stalin Knew. The Enigma of Barbarossa, Yale University piess, 2005, p. 162, .s 7uJ nroo'ltntfn ntTgnn ,t, 7y 7nt: ,nrzorDr n,n tnTnln :utn ,,n?ryn nroo'lrDtfn nrrTcnn ln-rN - l"tDl'Dtf .4 7u n,oo,IntTn n)9nnl r17ry;1 r)31 nt,n7 ltDx nrn .nilrl n,?xl n:tt:n n:Dn 7:,7 - l'7oo ,77:n nt')IDt nNytDil n'-tl .1943'l Ttrr: .r7p nTry: ni?pyn Finnish War. 1939-1940, Frank Cass, London ,2002, Foreword.;E. N.Kulkov (ed), Stalin and the Sovlet ,s DTIN ,"nDt-tNn nlDrnn' !g y1r1ryr11p1'1 nl7'yo? rtorf ituJDru ,ytn ntvtnn'tnrnn n,tnopn n-nnn .6 ,nliTolnl prn: nt?n x?? ntn,u ntT,ygn nN llnrD -luJN D'ntt't nNuJl Ell 13 I SlI"IrIJ:ltl I eo 1r'7rt ,2011 \tl
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjgzNzA=